‘Have you cooked the soup in the same cooker?’ Baba asked.
Asha had just stepped inside through the kitchen backdoor. She was watering the plants in the backyard. She went to the tap at the corner of the old-fashioned large kitchen and washed her hands and feet. Drying herself casually, she approached her father on the easy chair in the small sun kissed space outside kitchen.
‘Baba, how many pressure cookers do you think we have?’
The old man pushed away the soup bowl with disgust; the bowl clattered on the old marble console table, few drops of the liquid splattered on the polished white.
Asha gave him a side-eye and burst in a giggle. ‘Relax Baba, I have used the small cooker,’ she laughed and hugged her father. The old man gave in to her hug and tapped her arm affectionately.
‘I have to rush now. I have kept your food on the dining table. Have your food and meds on time. I will call you whenever free.’ Asha kept moving through the usual motions as she did everyday before going to the old age home where she worked as the Manager.
‘Don’t forget to take the garbage,’ her father reminded.
‘I have already kept it outside Baba,’ Asha spoke impatiently tucking her lunch box in bag.
‘Not that garbage,’ he said calmly and looked at her. Asha stopped in her tracks. Her face changed for a fleeting second; her eyes went cold and her jaws tightened. ‘Oh that, yes yes, I will take it,’ she answered and continued with the last-minute rushing around.
………..
Asha took the 6:40 train everyday. She reached the old age home by 8 am where she had been working as the manager for the past one year and few months. A quick 10 minutes’ walk to the railway station, 30 minutes in train followed by another 30 minutes in bus and then a few minutes in the nearby market buying a few essentials for the old age home – it was a routine that she followed everyday of the week.
As the train crossed a bridge over a canal, she dropped the garbage bag in the canal. A fellow passenger remarked, ‘Another lot?’ Asha nodded, her face masked in sadness and tired resignation. ‘Ma’s cosmetics’, she added, ‘Baba won’t part with a single object of her’s but it’s also aggravating his sickness. So, let this be!’ Few others consoled her, their words rushing past her ears with the breeze at the speeding train gate.
Asha reached her workplace a little before 8, her hands full with a bag of fresh supplies, another with fish, while she struggled to keep her shoulder bag in place. She went straight to the kitchen, handed over the bags to the cooks and proceeded to her office. Keeping her bag on the table, she called her father from her phone.
“Baba, I have reached.”
“Were you again standing at the train gate?”
“Yes Baba.”
“Try travelling the whole way by bus too.”
‘Yes Baba, will do so tomorrow.”
The day passed in a blur with Asha checking on the residents of the old age home, supervising their meals, the daily laundry and medical check up. She often sat with them, reading aloud stories to regale them and encouraged them too, to participate in recitation, crossword puzzles and other such activities to refresh their minds. After the night manager reached at 5 pm, Asha packed up for the day. She went to the kitchen to check on the dinner preparations. One of the cooks was chopping chicken for stew. Asha stood staring at the chopping board, rooted at the spot, the cook chopping the skinned chicken in small pieces with practiced precision. Someone gave her a nudge and she gasped in startlement. It was the other cook. “Asha Madam, we have almost run out of a few grocery items. Shall I give you the list now, or tomorrow?”
“Tomorrow!” Asha replied in a soft exclaim and left the kitchen in a rush. The cook looked after her for a while before going back to her work.
The train back home was a little late. Asha trudged on, dragging her tired feet through the last few metres to her home. She opened the small grill gate to the small bungalow designed house and stepped in. She wiped the sweat trickling down her forehead with the pallu of her saree and knocked at the door. Her father opened the door and smiled at her, “Welcome home dear.”
“Good evening Baba” she replied and entered.
“I have prepared tea for you,” her father said.
“I will freshen up in five minutes and join you for tea,” she replied.
The doorbell rang. Asha looked at the direction of the main door, a frown on her tired face.
The bell rang again.
Her father proceeded to open the door but Asha stopped him. She went and opened the door. A man stood in white shirt and black jeans, his serious face clearly not used to smiling. Two others stood behind him casually dressed. They were looking around the house curiously.
“Miss Asha Sarkar?” one of them asked.
“Yes” Asha replied warily.
“We are police Ma’am. May we come in? We have a few questions for you.”
“What questions?” Asha asked, now visibly nervous. She swallowed and wiped at her upper lip again with her pallu.
“Ma’am, please allow us to enter. Let’s sit and talk. Won’t take much of your time” the one in white shirt assured.
Asha led them to the drawing room. Old teakwood sofa, a glass top tea tree center table and 2 wall units filled with Bengali fiction – the room looked worn and lived in.
The three men sat on the sofa. Asha sat across them on another chair. Her father stood at the door, his face blank.
“Sir please. You may come in and sit. We need to talk to you as well.” The man in white shirt spoke to her father.
“What is it?” Asha asked.
“Do you know Sagar Choudhury?” the question came from the second man, who looked quiet younger than the man in white shirt. He had been observing her till then. Asha stared at him for a few seconds before replying.
“My husband.”
“Where is he?”
“What?” Asha exclaimed now.
“Madam, your husband has not returned home since Wednesday. He was last seen exiting his office at Dalhousie at 7 pm that day. His phone is switched off since then and he is missing.” The second man spoke.
Asha looked at them blankly. Clearly, she could not process the information.
“Ma’am, do you have any information about him?” the man in white shirt asked again.
Asha looked at her father, still blank and unable to respond.
“He doesn’t live here Officer—?” her father responded on her behalf.
The man stood up. He showed his ID now. “Pratap Mukherjee.”
He pointed at the second man and said, “He is from Shyambazar PS. SI Indrajeet Roy. And this is Constable Rakhal Mondal. He too, like me is from the local PS.”
“Pratap babu, my son-in-law doesn’t live here. However, he visits us twice or thrice a week. He came here last on Sunday night and left Monday morning with my daughter as she left for work.”
“Did you have any talk with him thereafter?” Pratap Mukherjee asked Asha.
“No,” Asha replied softly.
“No? Why? I mean, you did not talk to your husband for more than a week, neither did he call you, isn’t this strange?” Indrajeet asked now.
Asha took a deep breath and spoke. Her voice trembled, but her words were clear.
“He comes and goes as he feels like. I don’t get to ask him anything.”
“Why?’
“A little more than a year back I had escaped from his house while he slept in drunken stupor. I feared for my life. He had beaten me black and blue. I had a miscarriage few weeks before that.”
“Where did you go?”
“I came back here, destroyed my SIM and told my father to hide the truth from him.”
“You were a victim of domestic violence and yet, you never bothered to seek help!”
“Who would help? The beatings hardly ever left a mark; he was careful. And-” Asha paused, her face a bright red now,
“And?” Indrajeet persisted in his questioning.
“Marital rape isn’t a crime in India” Asha spoke in a barely audible voice.
The two officers exchanged glances,
“Brutality in bedroom can’t be proven,” Asha continued, her eyes glued to the floor, “I went to a lawyer after returning here. He said it would be a long drawn case. I wouldn’t be able to afford the expenses. And I would lose the case eventually.”
“And then?” Pratap Mukherjee asked.
“I hid. For a few months. Then I went out to try for a job. I got a job in an old age home, to supervise and manage the place from 8 am to 5 pm, six days a week. On Sundays I report to work for four hours.”
Please continue,” Indrajeet was relentless.
“About three months back, Sagar came here. He had seen me boarding a train and had followed me back home. He threatened to spread scandalous rumours about me which would be too much for my old father to bear.”
Pratap filled up a glass with water and pushed it towards her. Asha gulped some of it down and breathed heavily. Nobody spoke.
“I relented. I had no other option. I lost my mother when I was 12 years old. My father has brought me up since then. I did not want to lose my father too.”
“Did he continue the same behavior here too?” Pratap asked, his words a little hesitant now.
Asha nodded. Her lips trembled. She hung her head low and could not speak anymore.
“How did he behave on Sunday? Was everything….” Indrajeet left the question unfinished.
Asha looked up now. Her eyes shone with unshed tears. “Yes, he came, had dinner. I put Baba to sleep after his dinner. We….slept. Next day, we both went out together to station and caught different trains to our respective work places.”
“Slept?” Indrajeet asked. Asha’s eyes flashed in hurt and a rare show of anger, “Must I give you every graphic detail?”
Pratap touched Indrajeet’s shoulder and stopped him. He stood up, others followed.
“Ma’am, Sagar Choudhury is missing. If he comes here, or contacts you, please inform us.”
He gave his contact details to Asha and left with the rest.
As they left, Asha closed the door, double locked it and slumped to the floor. Her father stood there calmly looking at her and then spoke, “You did well. Go and freshen up. It’s late. We will have dinner and sleep.”
………………
Asha and Sagar had an arranged marriage. Asha had just completed her M.Com and her father’s colleague at the bank introduced Sagar’s family to them. Asha’s father was the Service Manager in a nationalized bank. Sagar’s father worked in railways. Sagar had just joined a private bank after completing his MBA. Sagar’s mother instantly liked her- Asha was fair, with almond eyes and an angular face. Little make up and her face looked quite attractive and adorable. Though slightly plump, her 5’5” height hid it well.
“Your daughter has such long and beautiful hair dada! Nowadays we hardly see girls her age maintain their hair so well!” she had remarked to Asha’s father.
Indeed, Asha had thick, wavy hair reaching almost her knees. Little did she know that Sagar would later pull at her hair as a bridle to treat her as a brood mare.
Sagar had all along been a class topper and ruthlessly ambitious. He crushed anyone who ever showed him at fault. He did not even spare Asha when early in marriage she made the mistake of giving a few inputs in a report he was working on. He was not a man needing anger management. He took pride in keeping his emotions under control and masking his thoughts at the workplace. At home, where the mask was not required, cruelty came naturally to him. The beatings were not out of a violent quarrel or angry altercation; it was over trivial things where Sagar found Asha lacking or ‘foolishly incompetent’. The violence came when the world had gone to sleep in showing her the right place ‘under him’, properly crushed, numbed with measured thrusts and slaps which left no visible marks.
Asha, at 24, did not know whom to pour her heart out to. She loved her husband as all girls are conditioned to. Sagar was pleasing to eyes and quite a charmer when around people. Her in laws treated her well, having no idea what she endured behind closed doors. Soon spending time alone with Sagar became a trauma for her; but the more she resisted, the more he got pleasure in tormenting her. She was his wife, his pet, his toy to play with as it pleased him. When Asha had her second miscarriage, her in laws were visiting their daughter at Delhi. Sagar had forbidden her from telling them anything, “Please don’t beat the drums on how careless and worthless you are as a woman that you can’t even hold a child inside you!” he had sneered at her in hospital.
Few days later, Sagar had returned home late reeking of whiskey and Asha had flinched with distaste at the stench. Sagar did not take that easily. His belt did the talking for him. Afterwards, as he lay in a drunken sleep, Asha had wiped the blood off her lips, packed her essentials in a suitcase and booked a cab back to her father’s home at Uttarpara.
Her father had looked at her long that night as he opened the door at one in the morning, his eyes burned in helpless anger and pain. Later, after she had a warm shower and sat shivering on her childhood bed, he brought her a glass of milk and a painkiller. He sat beside her as she gulped the milk down, washed off the medicine and then lay on her father’s lap tightly holding on to him. He had brushed her hair with his tired, old, trembling fingers until she had fallen asleep.
That was a long time back now. Asha needed some months to recover mentally though physically the wounds had ceased to hurt already. She took the job and on Sundays enjoyed working in the garden with her father and the gardener.
Then suddenly, Sagar reappeared one day in her life. He had followed her back from train. He had grinned an evil one at her, “So my dear wife thought she can hide from me in her father’s home! And my dear, dear father-in-law too, thought his daughter can run away from her husband’s home to continue living a life of debauchery here! What a joke!”
Asha did not give up. She sought a lawyer’s help. Then another. Then another. The replies were all the same, “Not a crime…can’t prove in a court of law…reconcile…talk to in laws…can’t afford the costs of case…”
Asha finally gave up. And Sagar continued coming whenever he could. He had sent his parents to his sister’s place when their questions about Asha became too irritating for him. The house at Shyambazar became a haven for drunken parties with close friends and other things, the details of which Asha had never wanted to know.
…….
Sagar had come unannounced on that Wednesday. It was quite late at night. Asha had given her father his night medicines and just completed cleaning the kitchen when there was a knock at the door. She opened the door and in the flash of thunder and light drizzle stood Sagar, smelling of liquor in a fashionable way. She had to allow him in. He followed her to kitchen.
“What’s for dinner?” he had asked.
“How would I know that you would come tonight? There’s nothing cooked right no…” Asha could not complete her words. Sagar casually hit her head on the kitchen door frame.
“Stupid woman,” he muttered and went to the bedroom. Her bedroom. She looked at the blood trickling down the wooden frame. “Stupid woman,” it echoed in her ears. She looked at the freshly washed mortar and pestle lying at a corner of the old kitchen. She looked at it for a long time.
She shook her head and went to the bedroom. “Will you have some noodles?” she asked. Sagar nodded. He gave her his phone. “Put this on charge. It got switched off just after I left office in the evening. I had forgotten to charge it during the day.” Asha took it and plugged it to the charger. Sagar did not notice that she missed the switch.
Asha went to the kitchen and put the noodles on boil. Calmly she took out her father’s medicine box and one by one, slowly, she peeled out the sedatives and crushed them in powder. She mixed it well in the hot noodles and took it to Sagar.
“Here, have it,” she had said. Sagar blew on the spoonsful of noodles and ate comfortably. He fell asleep even before finishing the food. Asha sat beside, calmly watching him breathe in sleep. The breathing which grew labored, and then as he struggled to breathe and yet sleep, Asha kept staring at him with unblinking eyes. She kept staring even after he had stopped breathing, even after he had gone cold, even when the first streaks of dawn coloured the eastern horizon red.
Asha’s father has always been an early riser; on Thursday too, he woke up at 4 am and seeing the lights on at Asha’s room and the door ajar, he came and stood there at the door.
“Is it all done? Or are you waiting for something more?” he had asked.
Asha looked up at him, unable to speak.
“The action, however done, is immaterial. It’s the aftermath that requires meticulous handling,” he spoke in the same way as he had done in her childhood when he taught her to grow a bougainvillea from a cutting.
Asha tried to speak but her mouth was dry as hay. Her father gave her the bottle of water and examined the wound at her temple.
“The head and the entrails,” he said, “get rid of them first. The stench will be damaging.”
Asha dragged the body to the kitchen. A corner of the kitchen was rounded off to block water from seeping out. There was a tap there. Asha blocked the drain hole with a brick. She lay the head in a tub and slowly sliced at the artery. Blood spurt out. All around. And then softly flowed into the tub.
Asha took the tub to the rose bed. Her father had dug the bed open. She poured the blood in the soil and walked inside as her father worked on filling up the bed again with the freshly dug soil.
She brought out the choppers used for hacking coconuts and trees. She chopped off the flesh from the body bit by bit, stifling the urge to wretch. She had to work fast lest the stench later made the work tougher. Hacking the limbs off was easy; it was the torso that broke her. The sight was too ghastly for her to endure. She thought she had known this ‘body’ intimately but now she realized, not this intimately. She heaved and retched, she hacked and retched – vomit and dead entrails in a wretched mix, lay at the kichen corner.
She took half a bucket of water and dipped the parts in it before tying them in old plastic packets. The head and the entrails, she packed last in two separate packets. The rest of the work was easy. Wipe the blood, mop the floor, throw the water in the backyard vegetable garden.
“Add fungicide,” her father had reminded, “else the plants will rot.”
She had packed the freezer of her side by side door refrigerator with the packets. She had called up at the old age home informing the night manager that she would arrive a little later. The fish pond on the way had seen the entrails become fish fodder. The head lay somewhere in the canal floor, thrown from the train.
And then for ten days, piece by piece, the body found its way to the 3 litre pressure cooker and then to the mixer-grinder before being washed down the toilet into the sewage tank. The harder bones found their way into the river bank along the cremation ground, dumpyards beside rail lines, canal water and many such places.
……
The police came again few days later. The house was bleach cleaned by then. Pratap Mukherjee had brought two others from Forensics. They questioned about the bleach in kitchen and bathroom. Asha replied, “My father turned 72 this July. I leave him alone in the house for a major part of the day. The kitchen is old, so is the bathroom. They get slippery easily. What if he slips and falls!”
Pratap Mukherjee looked at her for sometime and then asked in a no-nonsense voice, “Ms. Asha Sarkar, or should I say, Mrs. Asha Sagar Choudhury, I shall ask this only once and I will expect you to tell me the truth – do you have a hand in the disappearance of your husband?” And then, when Asha kept staring at him silently, he added, “Did you kill him?”
Asha kept staring in the same blank, numb manner and then said in a cold voice, “I wish I could. Officer, I would kill him if I could. But there is no such thing as a perfect murder and my father, at seventy-two, doesn’t deserve the last days of his life termed a s a criminal’s father. He deserves love and care, and that’s most important for me.”
The forensic team did not stay long thereafter.
Few days later, Pratap Mukherjee called her on phone and informed that they were closing the case as an unsolved one. However, if she ever got any news of her husband, she must inform him immediately. “At least for now am free from the beatings,” Asha said. Pratap had no fitting words to say. “Take care Madam,” he said before hanging up.
…..
It was a beautiful late October afternoon. Asha was watering her roses; her father lounged at the balcony sipping his tea. The plants had new shoots growing in a flourish. The baby leaves with their red rims looked fresh and promising. She was wearing her mother’s rose printed saree; the very saree she had worn the day Sagar’s parents had come to see her for the first time.
Someone stood at the gate watching the scene. Asha turned to have a look at the man. Constable Rakhal Mondal. Asha approached him and asked, “Anything to ask?” The middle-aged man smiled and shook his head. “I live close by. Your garden looks beautiful Asha Madam. The roses are beautiful,” he said. Asha calmly thanked him.
“You must have fed them quite an amount of blood meal. They are the best for roses,” he added.
Asha stared at him motionlessly.
Rakhal Mondal turned his cycle around waved at her, “Stay well Madam,” and rode away whistling a tune.
At a distance, the roses danced in the afternoon breeze.
*
Deboleena Sen Das is an English teacher based in West Bengal, India. She writes poetry,
short fiction and reflective prose, drawing inspiration from everyday life, nature, memory and the quiet complexities of human relationships. Her work explores resilience, identity and the emotional landscapes hidden within ordinary moments. She is an avid reader who believes that stories can illuminate both the world around us and the one within.








Relatable for present society